Well, it isn't me - but I thought the title would be shorter and fit more appropriately The question is for a client. I am by no means an expert, but merely offering basic obedience classes through the humane society. I have offerend my advice, I have given handouts and step to step directions on potty training. She states she has followed all of it. She is crate training, and she always takes him immediately outside to use the restroom.
Firstly, he is a nearly 6 month old goldendoodle. He was most likely from a puppy mill like situation. He had an indoor and outdoor portion of a kennel for a home up until he was adopted. But the problem didnt' spring up until just veyr recently.
For those that will suggest vet, the puppy has already seen a vet. Nothing wrong.. vet just says he's "bad".
She says everytime she takes him out, he DOES pee and poop outside. But when she brings him back inside, he will also pee inside too. He looks at her, and then just squats. (He is not neutered, he does not lift his leg to mark yet. I have already suggested that she neuter him shortly after he turns 6 months.) The vet suggested she rub his nose in it, and I of course told her the vet was wrong.
Should she restrict his water? I have heard of this before, but it being summer and getting hotter - I do not believe that to be particularly wise.
I have already suggested a tether, but she is not very optimistic because she says he does it right in front of her anyway.
Does anyone have any advice that I can pass onto her? It seems she is doing everything else right and I've been questioning suggesting a more aversive route because he's simply getting too old to be doing this.